MG vs Tata EVs: Which One Offers Better Value?

As the electric vehicle (EV) market in India heats up, two big players—MG Motor and Tata Motors—are going head to head. Both brands offer a compelling EV lineup, but the best choice for you depends on your priorities: budget, range, charging, or after-sales. Here’s a breakdown to help you decide which brand offers better value.

MG EVs: Premium Features & Range

• MG ZS EV

  • Equipped with a 50.3 kWh battery pack giving a claimed ARAI range of about 461 km.

  • Powerful motor: high torque, and 0-100 km/h in around 8.5 seconds.

  • Variants are priced from ₹18.98 lakh (Executive) up to ₹25.44 lakh for top models.

  • Comes with MG’s eShield warranty: 5-year unlimited km on car + 8-year / 1.5 lakh km on the battery, plus 24×7 roadside assistance.

  • MG is expanding its charging infrastructure via a partnership with Tata Power.

  • MG also launched the Comet EV — a small, city-friendly EV — with a lower entry price.

Strengths of MG EVs

• Long range (especially for the ZS EV)

• Strong warranty & support network

• More Premium feel & build

Trade-offs

• Higher upfront cost for larger MG EVs

• May be less cost-effective for strictly city driving

Tata EVs: Versatility & Affordability

• Tata Curvv EV

  • Available in 45 kWh and 55 kWh battery variants.

  • The 55 kWh model delivers an ARAI-claimed range of 585 km, while the 45 kWh variant offers up to 502 km.

  • Price starts at ₹17.49 lakh and goes up to around ₹21.99 lakh for the top variant.

  • Good safety: electronic stability control, 360° camera, and six airbags in some trims.

  • Practical size: slightly shorter than the ZS EV but still comfortable.

• Tata Nexon EV

  • One of the more affordable EV SUVs from Tata. According to CarHP, the Nexon EV’s lower-cost variants provide good value, especially for city driving.

  • Compatible with the growing Tata Power EZ-Charge network.

Strengths of Tata EVs

• Competitive pricing, especially in long-range and base EVs

• Multiple battery options provide flexibility

• Reliable after-sales and robust build

• Lower total cost for many city drivers

Trade-offs

• Less premium interior feel compared to MG ZS EV

• Some high-range variants may trade off power for efficiency

Value Comparison: MG vs Tata

Verdict:

• If you want maximum range and a higher-spec EV, the MG ZS EV is a strong pick — especially for longer trips or family use.

• If you’re looking for more flexible EV options at a lower or mid EV-SUV price, Tata’s EVs (especially the Curvv) may offer better value.

• For city-centric driving or budget EV usage, Tata’s entry-level EVs like the Nexon EV can be very practical.

FAQs

Q1. Is MG ZS EV better than Tata EVs for long drives?
A1. Yes — the MG ZS EV’s 50.3 kWh battery gives a very decent ARAI-rated range (around 461 km), making it quite capable for longer trips.

Q2. Which Tata EV has the longest range?
A2. The Tata Curvv EV offers two battery options, and its larger 55 kWh pack claims up to 585 km ARAI range.

Q3. What is MG’s warranty on their EVs?
A3. MG offers its eShield package: 5-year unlimited km vehicle warranty + 8-year / 1.5 lakh km for the battery + 5-year 24×7 roadside assistance.

Q4. Does Tata EVs have a good charging network?
A4. Yes. Tata has its EV charging ecosystem through Tata Power’s EZ Charge, offering a wide network for convenience.

Q5. Which brand is better for first-time EV buyers?
A5. For first-timers, Tata EVs (like the Curvv or Nexon EV) often make more financial sense due to lower starting prices, flexible battery options, and established service network.

Conclusion

Choosing between MG and Tata EVs comes down to what you value most: range and premium experience or cost-efficiency and practicality. MG’s ZS EV shines in range and comfort, while Tata’s EVs offer strong value, especially for battery-option flexibility and affordability. Evaluate your daily driving needs, total cost of ownership, and how far you plan to drive — then pick the EV that aligns with you.